Academia.eduAcademia.edu
Will Hizbullah Launch a Chemical Weapons Attack on Israel? Regional Realities Extinguish Probability Abstract The deteriorating situation in Syria has intensified the pressure on Israel to deliver the security that is critical for the Jewish state. While the presence of chemical weapons in Lebanon is still uncertain, defence sources claim that Syria has already moved Scud missiles to Hezbollah camps in Lebanon and erected advanced surface-to-air missiles in the Lebanese mountains. Any scenario in which Hizbullah or any other non-state actor had a chemical weapon capability the balance of deterrence between Israel and its regional adversaries would shift dramatically. The current speculation and belligerent rhetoric comes at a time of internal Lebanese dialogue over Hizbullah’s weapons and what role, legitimate or otherwise, the resistance’s arsenal plays in Lebanese security. Israel is rightly concerned with the escalating regional dynamics and a plausible threat from chemical weapons attack exists however Hizbullah would be an unlikely perpetrator. Evidence Supporting The CW Threat Scenario While the presence of chemical weapons in Lebanon is still uncertain, Kuwaiti newspaper, Al-Siyasa(2009) along with Israeli government and intelligence agencies have previously reported that Hezbollah was keeping chemical weapons in arms stockpiles in southern Lebanon which have exploded.In one instance three out of the eight Hezbollah operatives who were killed in the blast died after coming in contact with the chemicals however Lebanese Army personnel as well as UNIFIL (United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon) forces were denied access to the blast site in order to cover up any evidence. http://www.haaretz.com/news/report-chemical-weapons-in-hezbollah-arms-cache-blast-1.8552 For further evidence of past explosions involving Hizbullah munitions see: http://www.terrorism-info.org.il/en/article/18163 http://www.terrorism-info.org.il/malam_multimedia/English/eng_n/pdf/hezbollah_e014.pdf http://www.terrorism-info.org.il/malam_multimedia/English/eng_n/pdf/hezbollah_e012.pdf http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Terrorism-+Obstacle+to+Peace/Terrorism+from+Lebanon-+Hizbullah/Hizbullah-weapons-in-Southern-Lebanon-16-Jul-2009 Israeli defence sources claim that Syria has already moved Scud missiles to Hezbollah camps in Lebanon and erected advanced surface-to-air missiles in the Lebanese mountains. Any scenario in which Hizbullah or any other non-state actor had a chemical weapon capability the balance of deterrence between Israel and its regional adversaries would shift dramatically. Syria has the biggest chemical weapons stocks in the world with missiles and rockets that can reach any point in Israel, the Jewish state’s deputy military chief warned. Maj. Gen. Yair Naveh said if Syria had the chance, it would “treat us the same way it treats its own people.” http://www.haaretz.com/news/is-israel-really-a-target-for-chemical-warfare-1.263997 This belief has led the Netanyahu government to announce on the 12th of June, 2012 that it was going to mass distribute gas masks to protect its population against biological and chemical weaponry. This policy has been introduced several times since it was first announced in 1990 in the lead up to the Iraq War. http://articles.chicagotribune.com/1990-04-18/news/9002010342_1_gas-masks-israeli-newspapers-shlomi Israel’s Hayom daily (12th June, 2012) quoted a senior Israeli Defence official who warned that “the transference of chemical weaponry to Lebanon would be tantamount to a declaration of war by the Lebanese government” and “that Israel would act to prevent such a move”. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/middleeast/israel/9066222/Israel-We-will-act-to-prevent-Syrias-chemical-weapons-from-reaching-Hezbollah.html The current speculation and belligerent rhetoric comes at a time of renewed internal Lebanese National Dialogue. The National Dialogue facilitates the resumption of formal discussions between the various Lebanese parliamentary blocks that effectively stalled in November 2010 concerning primarily Hizbullah’s weapons and what role, legitimate or otherwise, the resistance’s arsenal plays in Lebanese security. Israel is rightly concerned with the escalating regional dynamics and a plausible threat from chemical weapons attack exists however Hizbullah would be an unlikely perpetrator. www.nti.org/gmap/?country/syria&layers=biological,chemical,missile,nuclear Hizbullah’s Chemical Weapons Capability Key strategic Syrian WMD production/storage facilities http://www.criticalthreats.org/lebanon/h Syria has successfully tested delivery systems for its chemical warheads, namely Scud B-C-D class missiles and Hizbullah has acknowledged that the Scud missile is a major component of its rejuvenated arsenal following the 2006 war. Given that Syria and Hizbullah’s military hardware are strategically linked, they have one of the largest ballistic missile arsenals in the region, made up of hundreds of Scud-derived missile systems. Their arsenal consists of older generation Soviet FROG-7, Scud-Bs, the solid-fuelled Scarab SS-21 as well as newer solid-fuelled and liquid fuelled missiles with imported components from China and Scud-C and the longer range Scud-D’s from North Korea. http://www.nti.org/analysis/articles/weapons-mass-destruction-middle-east/ Israeli intelligence warns that the transfer of unconventional weapons to the Hizbullah commenced following the 2006 conflict with Israel, however the weapons remain on Syrian territory to prevent their destruction in an Israeli strike. Should Hizbullah relocate its Scud D missiles, which can reach any point in Israel, and other advanced weapons, including anti-air missiles, out of secret storage in Syria and transfer them across the border to Lebanon then Israel would be forced to act on its promise that Hizbullah’s Scuds would be destroyed. It is believed that Hizbullah has kept its most advanced hardware stashed at the Syrian Al Hame and Al Zabadani military bases near Damascus. An emboldened Free Syrian Army declare’s that securing the Assad regimes military assets are a priority and the most intense fighting between Syrian opposition groups and pro Assad forces has occurred in areas that correspond with Syria’s weapons storage facilities (Aleppo, Homs, Hama and Latakia). The situation has forced Tehran and Hizballah leaders to generate an expedited relocation strategy. Israeli Defence Force officials point to diversionary tactics such as engaging Hamas, Islamic Jihad, Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine, Popular Resistance Committees, Ansar al-Sunna,  Force 17, Army of Islam, Tawhid wal-Jihad or Abdullah Azzam Brigades to either supply cover the weapons transfer or to open up a broader front incorporating all Israel’s borders, not just its northern frontier, from which to launch a vigorous attack against Israel. One plan is to enlist the Palestinian Jihad Islami in the Gaza Strip and exploit a clash over the Scuds’ transfer as a trigger for an all round military offensive against Israel. It would be timed for the moment the Western-Arab intervention in Syria against President Assad crosses the line between covert and overt military action and begins an operation to establish safe zones as bases for rebel operation. http://www.debka.com/article/22053/Turkey-ditches-Syrian-rebels-Will-Israel-attack-Hizballah-s-Scuds- A CW attack on one of Israel’s major population centres would be catastrophic. The densely populated areas of Tel Aviv, Haifa or the Galilee would be priority targets for such an attack and within range of Hizbullah’s current missile capability. Accoring to the Council on Foreign Relations(2006) and DEBKAfile(2012), Syria has produced, tested and continues to store VX nerve which is the deadliest nerve agent ever created. The only countries that have admitted to having VX or a closely related agent are the United States and Russia. (The United States has destroyed about 9 percent of its VX stockpile, and Russia has promised to eliminate its own supply of a VX-like agent.) Experts say Iraq successfully weaponized VX sometime in the late 1980s. There were reports that Syria successfully produced VX or a similar agent and tested missile warheads armed with VX. http://www.cfr.org/weapons-of-terrorism/vx/p9556 http://www.debka.com/article/22043/ A fraction of a drop of VX, absorbed through the skin, can fatally disrupt the nervous system and although an antidote is available, the chemical is absorbed so rapidly that unless victims received immediate medical attention the casualty rate would be extremely high. If one recalls the shocking effects of a VX release by Aum Shinrikyo on the Tokyo subway network in 1995 then the agents devastating potential is clear. Sources claim that Saddam Hussein used VX against the Iranian’s during the Iran-Iraq War and again in a 1988 chemical attack on Iraqi Kurds at Halabja which resulted in the deaths of 5,000 people and left a horrific medical legacy for thousands more. Ibid. VX is highly unstable and thus only an organisation with a high technical capability would be able to handle to weaponization and handling process. If Hizbullah has such technical ability among its ranks then it would shatter the stereotype espoused by the Israeli’s of the Resistance’s (Hizbullah) poor uneducated martyr’s and add considerable credibility to Israel’s current threat scenario. Hizbullah's regional offensive capability deeply concerns Israeli officials Hizbullah was implicated in a series of events in Thailand, India, Azerbaijan and Georgia as well as prosecutions in the US for individuals associated with the Hizbullah. http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/features/2012/02/201222111849914483.htmlOn the 21st of March, 2012 the Republican chairman of the House Homeland Security Committee, Peter King, said “the Iranian-backed Lebanese group Hezballah may have hundreds of operatives based in the United States”, adding that “Hezballah, and not al-Qaida, poses the greatest terrorist threat to Americans” http://www.debka.com/newsupdate/367/ http://www.foreignpolicyjournal.com/2012/03/24/us-ambassador-feltman-pledges-no-interference-in-lebanon/. Iran requires that Hizbullah maintains an effective presence in the region especially with the uncertainty facing its operational ally Syria. With officials claiming that a pre-emptive strike on Iran will unleash a barrage onto Israel’s northern border coupled with Nasrallah’s insistence that Tel Aviv is within rocket range, the outcome of renewed IAEA negotiations which commenced in May 2012 has intensified the focus on Hizbullah’s intentions. http://www.imra.org.il/story.php3?id=56740 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/29/magazine/will-israel-attack-iran.html?pagewanted=all Several of Syria’s opposition groups have indicated that a post-Assad Syria would seek to return the Golan Heights to Syrian sovereign control. Such action would present a dilemma for Hizbullah as they would support and no doubt take part in any attempt to liberate the Golan however the successful return of the highly strategic area to Syrian control would require Hizbullah to negotiate several contentious issues that legitimize Hizbullah’s al Mukawama (Resistance) The Sheba’a Farms are located on the slopes of Mt. Hermon near the borders of Lebanon, Syria and since 1967, Israel. The area has been the topic of confusion dating back to the 1914 Sykes/Picot Agreement and the inaccuracies by the French border demarcation. The Lebanese government and the current Syrian regime agree that the Farms are Lebanese territory. For official Party discussion see Qassem. N. (2007). Hizbullah: The Story from Within. p.p.239-241. Saqi:London . Perhaps Israeli focus could shift to actors such as Abu Musab al-Suri, a Syrian born Jihadist who was released from a Damascus prison in February 2012 with intintmate connections to Osama Bin Laden along with those who follow the al Qaeda ‘HYDRA’ ideology.which calls for al Qaeda Core or the central command structure currently headed by Ayman al Zawahiri to be replaced by an organization that has a multitude of loosely linked groups who are united under the global jihadist ideology. For more information see: A-Suri: Ideological jihad must lead to use of weapons of mass destruction Before 9/11, Al-Suri (real name Mustafa Setmariam Nasar) worked as facilitator who ushered Western reporters into the presence of bin Laden in Afghanistan. In October, 2005, he published on the Web a book of 1,600 pages entitled “A Call to a Global Islamic Resistance." http://www.debka.com/weekly/trial/ http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303299604577323750859163544.html US, Lebanese and Turkish officials, the United Nations as well as the Assad regime openly acknowledge the active presence of al Qaeda militants in Syria and Lebanon while al Zawahiri has repeatedly announced throughout 2012 via video messages and interviews that Syria is a nascent theatre for jihadist operations. http://www.google.com.au/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=al+zawahiri+calls+for+al+qaeda+in+Syria&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CGMQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.csmonitor.com%2FWorld%2FMiddle-East%2F2012%2F0212%2FAl-Qaeda-s-Zawahiri-calls-for-war-to-oust-Syria-s-Assad&ei=CUXmT4bHHsS5iQe3ycxZ&usg=AFQjCNHYQw754_CpTruXLRk9uWlViAM9hQ Hizbullah’s reliance and or independence with Syria and Iran will be tested during the next phase of regional developments and will be scrutinized from within Hizbullah’s executive council (political) and External Security Branch (military) as well as those who may wish to capitalize on an otherwise occupied adversary. Events outside of Lebanon will influence Hizbullah’s legitimacy http://www.dailystar.com.lb/News/Politics/2012/May-19/173953-charbel-no-al-qaeda-in-lebanon-ghosn-claims-unfounded.ashx#axzz1vjLHD0ni http://www.google.com.au/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=al+zawahiri+calls+for+al+qaeda+in+Syria&source=web&cd=14&ved=0CGgQFjADOAo&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.stratfor.com%2Fweekly%2Fjihadist-opportunities-syria&ei=XkXmT8mqKa-viQeMldlY&usg=AFQjCNGw074sCGEApcgOLCvMsh3u7H4iXw http://www.dailystar.com.lb/News/Politics/2012/May-24/174474-hezbollah-arms-will-stay-while-israel-poses-threat.ashx#axzz1vjLHD0ni for the first time in the Party’s existence. If the Party continues its current measured approach Hizbullah will permeate but not dominate discussion over what course the Arab Uprising will take next whilst the ambiguity concerning Hizbullah’s pro-active military intentions will further marginalize Israel and its anticipated military response? Patrick Blannin 15thJune, 2012